Fic­tion

The Third Temple

  • Review
By – November 25, 2024

Yishai Sarid is renowned for his star­tling por­traits of con­tem­po­rary Israeli soci­ety, such as The Mem­o­ry Mon­ster, a dis­qui­et­ing work about the uses of Holo­caust remem­brance and ped­a­gogy, and Vic­to­ri­ous, a haunt­ing char­ac­ter study of a moral­ly com­pro­mised woman whose healthy libido, black humor, and acer­bic obser­va­tions help her to cope (up to a point) with Israel’s mil­i­taris­tic soci­ety. These and oth­er nov­els wres­tle with the oppres­sive weight of mem­o­ry, his­to­ry, and oblig­a­tion on the lives of their embat­tled protagonists.

Sarid’s lat­est nov­el, The Third Tem­ple, won the Bern­stein Prize and has received acco­lades for its unflinch­ing por­trait of a postapoc­a­lyp­tic, monar­chic Jew­ish soci­ety still at odds with its ene­mies. A mas­ter­ful indict­ment of fun­da­men­tal­ist and mes­sian­ic ide­olo­gies, and a prob­ing med­i­ta­tion on Jew­ish pow­er and pow­er­less­ness over time, the book is writ­ten with a great deal of integri­ty and soul — and is per­haps the most essen­tial Israeli nov­el in recent memory.

In an inde­ter­mi­nate future, after the monar­chic King­dom of Judah” has been con­quered by the Amalekites,” Prince Jonathan, the youngest son of self-anoint­ed King Jehoaz, is tak­en pris­on­er and com­pelled by his cap­tors to write the chron­i­cles of what has tran­spired. Sex­u­al­ly dis­abled since child­hood by a terrorist’s grenade, he has nev­er been allowed to bask in the pub­lic glo­ry of Judean roy­al­ty as his old­er broth­ers do. Until the kingdom’s col­lapse, he super­vised the priests of the Third Tem­ple, whose lives are ded­i­cat­ed to the sac­ri­fi­cial butch­ery of an extrav­a­gant num­ber of lambs, rams, bulls, and oth­er hap­less crea­tures on the bloody altar — all while the pop­u­la­tion begins to starve. For Prince Jonathan, his roy­al father has become as remote a fig­ure as God him­self, yet he still dotes on him, despite being embit­tered by the fact that after his mother’s death, the king mar­ried the decades-younger woman Jonathan has loved obses­sive­ly since child­hood. From his dank prison cell, Jonathan nar­rates his strug­gles to stay res­olute as rumors of mil­i­tary dis­as­ters increas­ing­ly unset­tle the king­dom, and even as he receives tor­ment­ing vis­i­ta­tions from an angel of the Lord who com­mands him to chal­lenge the king’s author­i­ty (that angel­ic mes­sen­ger is ter­ri­fy­ing in some scenes and a source of the novel’s rare moments of com­ic relief in oth­ers, and turns out to be as vul­ner­a­ble to human cru­el­ty as the rest of God’s creations).

In this unspar­ing nov­el, Sarid casts a steady gaze on the foibles of Israeli soci­ety in the present, not least when it comes to the cor­rup­tion and law­less­ness of the insu­lat­ed monarch who rules over the suf­fer­ing mass­es as if he were tru­ly God’s gift to the Jews — even when events prove otherwise.

One of Sarid’s gifts as a nov­el­ist has long been his abil­i­ty to cre­ate dis­af­fect­ed and mem­o­rable pro­tag­o­nists whose haunt­ing voic­es linger in read­ers’ minds long after they reach the final page; and the aching­ly poignant, tor­ment­ed fig­ure at the heart of this grip­ping nov­el is no excep­tion. Orig­i­nal­ly pub­lished in Hebrew in 2015, the nov­el feels all the more urgent and time­ly now, even with its indul­gent soupçons of the super­nat­ur­al. In the tra­di­tion of the most pow­er­ful dystopi­an nov­els, it is a mir­ror of our own time, reflect­ing both the tick­ing time bomb of Israel’s grow­ing inter­nal strug­gle with reli­gious extrem­ists and the relent­less hos­til­i­ty of its exter­nal ene­mies. Viewed through the prism of the present moment, it reads like a ten­der paean to all the vul­ner­a­ble vic­tims of the vio­lent pol­i­tics of the Mid­dle East. Yardenne Greenspan’s nim­ble trans­la­tion cap­tures the wry wit, tense dra­ma, and pathos of Sarid’s lan­guage. An auda­cious nov­el ful­ly con­ver­sant with Hebrew lit­er­ary tra­di­tions going back to Jere­mi­ah, as well as with con­tem­po­rary postapoc­a­lyp­tic nar­ra­tives, The Third Tem­ple is somber­ly poet­ic, keen­ly satir­i­cal, and grim­ly prophetic.

Ranen Omer-Sher­man is the JHFE Endowed Chair in Juda­ic Stud­ies at the Uni­ver­si­ty of Louisville and edi­tor of the forth­com­ing book Amos Oz: The Lega­cy of a Writer in Israel and Beyond.

Discussion Questions