As the commandant of Auschwitz Rudolph Hoess perfected and oversaw the gas chambers where an estimated one million people were exterminated. Jurg Amann, a distinguished author and playwright, has carefully synthesized Hoess’s original memoir into a highly readable monologue. This work is of great significance because it provides invaluable insights regarding the inner world of someone capable of monstrous evil carried out under a veneer of duty, loyalty, and worship of an ideal. In this work Amann, unintentionally, further demolishes Hannah Arendt’s psychologically naive view that Hoess, Eichmann, and other bureaucratic functionaries of the Nazi genocidal regime can be viewed as ordinary or banal.
There is nothing remotely banal in Hoess’s chilling self –revelation. Amann, via his editorial craftsmanship, is able to capture an utterly soulless individual whose respect for life and capacity for authentic love were destroyed at a very early age. What is left is a shell of a human being who dedicates himself to an unswerving commitment to a Germanic military ideal. This fanatic devotion is subsumed into a reverence for Hitler and the SS ideology which enables Hoess to view each of his killing assignments as if they were delegated tasks in a large corporation . His mind is obsessed with notions of efficiency, speed, and order. His conflation of running an annihilation center as if he were the CEO of a large meat processing plant underscores an unfathomable degree of psychopathology.
There is no questioning of the Final Solution save for a few comments to the effect that if Hoess were in charge he would have chosen a different approach to the “Jewish problem.” The genocide of the Jews, he wrote, was wrong because “the cause of anti-Semitism was not served by this act at all, in fact, just the opposite. The Jews have come much closer to their final goal.”
Jurg Amann has done a great service by making Hoess’s memoir available to students of the Holocaust but, most importantly, to the young of the current and future generations. The Commandant is a must read for all social scientists and clinicians seeking a graphic and compelling self portrait of the evolution of ideological and bureaucratic sociopathy. Afterword, editor’s note.
Nonfiction
The Commandant
- Review
By
– February 23, 2012
Steven A. Luel, Ph.D., is associate professor of education and psychology at Touro College, New York. He is a developmental psychologist and psychoanalyst in private practice. He is co-editor (with Paul Marcus) of Psychoanalytic Reflections on the Holocaust: Selected Essays.
Discussion Questions
Jewish literature inspires, enriches, and educates the community.
Help support the Jewish Book Council.