By
– August 30, 2011
In Holly Thompson’s Orchards, Kanako Goldberg, a half-Jewish half-Japanese eighth grader, is sent from her American home to her mother’s family farm in Japan after Ruth, a bi-polar classmate, hangs herself in a nearby orchard. Although Kanako insists she did nothing, it is clear that Ruth was bullied. Her mother says, “You can reflect in the presence of your ancestors.” The narrative, told in scant but honest and emotional poetry to Ruth, grapples with issues of guilt, responsibility, and healing. But Orchards is not just about bullying and suicide; it is also about family and privilege. Kanako’s Japanese family share baths, work hard, and live frugally. Her grandmother still resents Kanako’s father. As Kanako adjusts to her new routine, she talks to Ruth about Japan as well as what happened at home. Her resentment at the banishment turns to understanding and personal growth, and eventually, Kanako reaches out to Ruth’s friend, Jake, and makes teshuvah to Ruth. The ending satisfies. While sad, it is what forgiveness should beempowering and thought provoking. Orchards is not overly graphic or preachy. Readers who don’t love verse novels may wish for more dialogue and scene, but those who want to experience the intimate thoughts of a young girl grappling with self revelation and guilt will find the voice gripping, believable, and sympathetic. Other books about bullying include The Girls, by Amy Goldman Koss (for younger readers). Teachers may want to pair this book with the stark film, It’s a Girl’s World, for an open and important, life saving discussion. Ages 12 and up.
Sarah Aronson holds an MFA in Writing for Children and Young Adults from Vermont College. She is a full time writer and has recently published her first novel, Head Case (Roaring Brook) for young adults. Sara blogs every Thursday for the Lilith blog.