Non­fic­tion

Hen­ri­et­ta Szold: Hadas­sah and the Zion­ist Dream

By – March 4, 2024

The name Hen­ri­et­ta Szold has long been syn­ony­mous with Hadas­sah, the orga­ni­za­tion she found­ed. That was a tow­er­ing achieve­ment: for more than a cen­tu­ry, Hadas­sah has pro­vid­ed life-chang­ing and life-sav­ing med­ical ser­vices in Israel, and today it is by far the largest Jew­ish mem­ber­ship orga­ni­za­tion in America. 

Yet, as Francine Klags­brun demon­strates in this biog­ra­phy, Szold did much more than cre­ate that mas­sive and essen­tial insti­tu­tion. She also played a key role in the pub­li­ca­tion of two land­mark works of Jew­ish schol­ar­ship. As a trans­la­tor and edi­tor at the Jew­ish Pub­li­ca­tion Soci­ety, she worked close­ly with Louis Ginzberg on his mul­ti-vol­ume Leg­ends of the Jews, and with Mar­cus Jas­trow on his Dic­tio­nary of the Tal­mud, Midrash and Tar­gu­mim. Both works remain stan­dard ref­er­ences today.

Szold was a Zion­ist even before Theodor Her­zl pub­lished The Jew­ish State. Her­zl lat­er asked her to orga­nize Jew­ish women in Amer­i­ca around Zion­ism, and in 1912, a group of women found­ed the Hadas­sah chap­ter of Daugh­ters of Zion.” By 1917, they were a nation­al Zion­ist orga­ni­za­tion with thir­ty-three chap­ters, called, sim­ply, Hadas­sah.” 

In her trav­els to Ottoman Pales­tine, Szold saw first­hand the ill effects of malar­ia and unclean liv­ing con­di­tions. This prompt­ed her to raise hun­dreds of thou­sands of dol­lars — in today’s dol­lars, more than three mil­lion — to bring dozens of doc­tors and nurs­es to Pales­tine. Lat­er, after mov­ing there, she became act­ing direc­tor of the Amer­i­can Zion­ist Med­ical Unit, and over­saw the work of four hun­dred med­ical pro­fes­sion­als with­out hav­ing had any med­ical train­ing her­self — a vivid demon­stra­tion of her nat­ur­al lead­er­ship abilities.

That alone would have been an extra­or­di­nary achieve­ment, but there’s more. Rec­og­niz­ing the neces­si­ty of orga­niz­ing pub­lic edu­ca­tion in Pales­tine, Szold spent three months in the US rais­ing funds. There, she attract­ed a lead­ing Amer­i­can edu­ca­tor to join her in Pales­tine. See­ing that social ser­vices were min­i­mal, she helped orga­nize social work­ers to assist fam­i­lies. And she was fear­less: when financier Felix War­burg, a top offi­cial at the Jew­ish Agency, tried to inter­fere with her plans, she bold­ly con­front­ed him.

With the rise of the Nazism in Ger­many, Szold orga­nized the Youth Aliyah to reset­tle Ger­man chil­dren in kib­butz­im — chil­dren whom she per­son­al­ly vis­it­ed again and again. She trav­eled to Hitler’s Berlin to help coor­di­nate efforts there, and raised mon­ey to res­cue chil­dren flee­ing Roma­nia and the Sovi­et Union. Szold was tru­ly self­less: when Hadas­sah made her a gift of twen­ty-five thou­sand dol­lars in hon­or of her eight­i­eth birth­day, she used it to cre­ate a girls’ shel­ter for daugh­ters of poor fam­i­lies. Her life is a mod­el of giv­ing: she devot­ed her con­sid­er­able tal­ents to the wel­fare of others.

Francine Klags­brun is the ide­al biog­ra­ph­er for Szold. Deeply learned in Jew­ish life and cul­ture, she recounts both the heart­break and the tri­umphs of a great Jew­ish leader, with enor­mous empa­thy for Szold’s per­son­al dis­ap­point­ments as well as deep appre­ci­a­tion for her intel­lect, courage, resource­ful­ness, and accom­plish­ments. It’s a com­pelling and inspir­ing story.

Discussion Questions

Cour­tesy of Francine Klagsbrun

  1. How much did you know about Hen­ri­et­ta Szold before you read this book? What would you say were her major accomplishments?
  2. Szold’s father exert­ed great influ­ence on her dur­ing her grow­ing up years. What ben­e­fits did she gain from her close­ness to him? What detri­ments did she suf­fer from that closeness?
  3. What did Hen­ri­et­ta Szold mean when she said, Zion­ism con­vert­ed me to itself?” How did the Russ­ian immi­grants she met influ­ence her think­ing about Zion­ism and Judaism? How did her vision of Zion­ism dif­fer from that of Theodor Her­zl and lat­er David Ben-Gurion?
  4. What were her major accom­plish­ments as Sec­re­tary of the Jew­ish Pub­li­ca­tion Soci­ety? In what ways did her work there influ­ence her think­ing? How did she influ­ence the Jew­ish cul­tur­al world through that work?
  5. While study­ing at the Jew­ish The­o­log­i­cal Sem­i­nary, Hen­ri­et­ta Szold fell mad­ly in love with Pro­fes­sor Louis Ginzberg, and was dev­ast­ed when he chose anoth­er woman. Do you think she read more into his feel­ings for her than he ever had, or did he exploit her for his own pur­pos­es and then betray her? How dif­fer­ent do you imag­ine her life would have been had she mar­ried Louis Ginzberg?
  6. After say­ing that she didn’t believe in sep­a­rate women’s orga­ni­za­tions, why do you think Szold found­ed Hadas­sah as a women’s Zion­ist orga­ni­za­tion? How had her trip to Pales­tine influ­ence her think­ing about the mis­sion Hadas­sah need­ed to under­take? How did Hadassah’s goals dif­fer from the goals of male Zion­ist organizations?
  7. We need Zion­ism as much as those Jews do who need a phys­i­cal home,” Szold wrote to a friend. What did she mean by that? Why did she believe Hadas­sah women could be good Zion­ists with­out nec­es­sar­i­ly liv­ing in the Land of Israel?
  8. After her moth­er died, Szold turned down an offer from a male friend to say Kad­dish for the deceased woman, main­tain­ing that women have an equal oblig­a­tion with men to say that prayer. What oth­er con­tri­bu­tions did Szold make regard­ing women’s rights? Would you con­sid­er her a fem­i­nist leader?
  9. Szold nev­er mar­ried or had chil­dren, yet she became known as a moth­er in Israel.” How did she earn that title? Why did she con­sid­er her work with Youth Aliyah the most worth­while under­tak­ing” she had ever been involved with?
  10. Although Hen­ri­et­ta Szold didn’t go to col­lege or have spe­cial­ized train­ing in any pro­fes­sion, she suc­cess­ful­ly ran a Hadas­sah med­ical unit in pre-state Israel and lat­er head­ed the edu­ca­tion and social ser­vice depart­ments in that land. What skills did she have that made it pos­si­ble for her to han­dle such assign­ments? What per­son­al qual­i­ties made peo­ple trust her?
  11. Szold cared deeply about peace between Jews and Arabs. To that end, she advo­cat­ed for a bina­tion­al state to be shared equi­tably between the two peo­ples. Do you think she would still hold that posi­tion today?
  12. What do you con­sid­er Szold’s lega­cy to be, for both Amer­i­can and Israeli Jews?