By
– December 21, 2011
Faced with the rising criticism of David Ben-Gurion in recent decades from revisionist historians and anti-Zionists, Shlomo Aronson has written a densely argued apologia pro sua vita. He certainly succeeds in rescuing this remarkable figure, even if the reader sometimes wonders if it could have been achieved with fewer words.
A voracious, self-taught reader and thinker, Ben-Gurion was somewhat sensitive about his lack of formal education. It feels as if the author shares some of that discomfort and sets out in a long opening chapter to detail Ben-Gurion’s intellectual forebears. He constructs a complex theory of a moment in history he calls the Jewish Renaissance in order to explain the omnivorousness and essential practicality of Ben-Gurion, when these traits can be plainly defended by his unique success.
These small flaws aside, the book is extremely valuable. Aronson refutes Ben-Gurion’s many detractors, deflecting accusations of all stripes. He explains the real world that the Jewish leader inhabited, the horrible “trap” of the Holocaust, the unrealistic and damaging activities of the Zionist Left and Right of his day. And through this intellectual biography, Aronson educates the reader on the background history of Zionism, and its anything but assured success.
A voracious, self-taught reader and thinker, Ben-Gurion was somewhat sensitive about his lack of formal education. It feels as if the author shares some of that discomfort and sets out in a long opening chapter to detail Ben-Gurion’s intellectual forebears. He constructs a complex theory of a moment in history he calls the Jewish Renaissance in order to explain the omnivorousness and essential practicality of Ben-Gurion, when these traits can be plainly defended by his unique success.
These small flaws aside, the book is extremely valuable. Aronson refutes Ben-Gurion’s many detractors, deflecting accusations of all stripes. He explains the real world that the Jewish leader inhabited, the horrible “trap” of the Holocaust, the unrealistic and damaging activities of the Zionist Left and Right of his day. And through this intellectual biography, Aronson educates the reader on the background history of Zionism, and its anything but assured success.
Jeff Bogursky reads a lot, writes a little and talks quite a bit. He is a media executive and expert in digital media.