Poet­ry

A Pre­cise Chaos

  • Review
By – June 30, 2025

How can con­tem­po­rary Jew­ish poets ade­quate­ly respond to the his­to­ry of our time when it is con­tin­u­al­ly and rapid­ly revis­ing itself? How do we describe coun­tries, lan­guages, and bor­ders that we expe­ri­enced but that no longer exist; artic­u­late the slip­page of polit­i­cal beliefs that we thought were unshake­able; and remem­ber ances­tors whom we can nei­ther locate nor even begin to imag­ine? Final­ly, what foun­da­tion can we dis­cov­er, and hold in our grasp, to keep our­selves in bal­ance against these swift­ly chang­ing narratives? 

Mort’s implied answer to these ques­tions — unfold­ing over the course of a lyri­cal jour­ney through Mostar, Paris, Berlin, Birke­nau, Gdan­sk, Jeri­cho, Jerusalem, Nablus, and New York City— lies in the pow­er of poet­ic mem­o­ry itself. Unlike offi­cial” mem­o­ries offered by news media and nation­al insti­tu­tions, poets can lay­er oppos­ing his­to­ries on top of each oth­er, insist­ing that we keep the dif­fer­ent real­i­ties present in our consciousness:

I rec­og­nize the hotel on the evening news.

You tell me the out­door café

is now a mass grave, bod­ies piled on top of the patio

where I sat a year ago, sip­ping cold beer served

by a wait­er in a for­mal vest and bow tie.

(“In Mostar, City of Bridges”)

In this and oth­er poems, Mort jux­ta­pos­es and offers her own remem­brances, which are star­tling, beau­ti­ful, and some­times painful. When it comes to the Mid­dle East, Mort notes sar­don­ical­ly in this coun­try even the ghosts have ghosts” (“In the Kin­neret Ceme­tery”), and at a par­ty in Jeri­cho she writes:

We look around the room—

pick out the for­tu­nate ones:

a Span­ish jour­nal­ist, me …

… and then the rest

who return home to Beit Hanina,

the neigh­bor­hood with­out passports.

(“Night­time in Jericho”). 

Ful­ly aware of the severe inequities gov­ern­ing rela­tions between Israelis and Pales­tini­ans (the poet iron­i­cal­ly refers to non-Pales­tine” in her poem Route 443”), Mort depicts cities like Beth­le­hem as sur­re­al spaces where Good Shep­herd Beer stalls are flanked by Israeli jeeps. At the same time, she mar­vels at an Ortho­dox woman pray­ing in a sub­way car back in New York and cel­e­brates the beau­ti­ful voice of a female rab­bi in an Amer­i­can synagogue. 

For Mort, it is the poet’s job to con­tin­u­al­ly weave togeth­er these dif­fer­ent accounts and these dif­fer­ent under­stand­ings of being Jew­ish now — ask­ing us to sit with all of them. 

Appro­pri­ate­ly, at a read­ing in New York, where a friend reads poems about Jerusalem at the French Cul­tur­al cen­ter, Mort asks her­self and us:

Who are we, poets

and fans, to push the essence of the war

away from our faces, out of our minds,

even for an hour as we praise metaphor

over answers? Even ask­ing a ques­tion is enough—

an impor­tant beginning…

(“Time Zones”)

Mort repeat­ed­ly asks ques­tions about poet­ry, about Jew­ish iden­ti­ty, and about who we are as peo­ple in the ear­ly twen­ty-first cen­tu­ry, in ways that are both unset­tling and invigorating:

Say what will become of us.

What will we become?

(“In the Kin­neret Cemetery”)

Discussion Questions