By
– August 31, 2011
In a dignified small picture book, narrative and landscape blend lyrically to tell the story of how God came to choose Mount Sinai as the place to give the Ten Commandments. Rosenstock adapted this ancient legend of “The Contest of the Mountains” from the Midrash Bereshit Rabbah. People have not been treating each other well, and God wants to give them rules to live by. Each mountain steps forward to claim the honor. Mount Carmel brags about its lushness; Mount Herman boasts about the popularity of its peaks and streams; Mount Tabor claims a place in history for rising above the floodwaters. After others, too, trumpet their superiority, God selects rocky Mount Sinai for humbly staying out of the fray and trusting God to make the decision. Language is direct and chiseled. Though the mountains are personified in words, they are always mountains in the illustrations, grandly painted in a pastel palette that bleeds to the edges of double-page spreads. In some, insets frame the actions of people. Sources are given. All in all a solid choice. For ages 3 – 7.
Sharon Elswit, author of The Jewish Story Finder and a school librarian for forty years in NYC, now resides in San Francisco, where she shares tales aloud in a local JCC preschool and volunteers with 826 Valencia to help students write their own stories and poems.